Margulis did not only posit endosymbiosis
as a source of organelles. REF? She posited that all novelties in eukaryotes
are caused by endosymbiosis. In her opinion, bacteria are involved in an
intelligent network covering the whole planet. In addition to working to the
best for eukaryotes in a teleological manner it also supports our planet and maintains
it in best possible ways. This theory was worked out in cooperation with James
Lovelock. It is the "Gaia theory". The intelligence in her model is thereby Gaia
herself.
This way to regard bacteria can be seen as
a solution to a serious problem in her scenario for cellular evolution. The problem
is the origin of bacteria. According to the endosymbiosis theory their fusion
starts evolution in a colossal tempo in eukaryotes. But the bacteria hardly
evolve at all. That could be explained by the combination being so powerful.
But there is another major problem. With Darwinian evolution even the bacteria
must have evolved from single molecules. If Gaya created bacteria, then the
problem is solved. Margulis criticized Darwinism especially because it is based
on random mutations, which as she said:
“Neo-Darwinism, which insists on (the slow
accrual of mutations), is in a complete funk.”
I have illustrated Margulis´ way of thinking in the figure below:
and my way in this figure:
Organisms are illustrated by circles where complexity is the size of the circles. Evolvability is illustrated by the thickness of the arrows that show the direction of evolution. My theories do not rely on any intelligence. Instead they rely on evolvability, which is present in eukaryotes today, and which has been present almost from the beginning. There are a range of mechanisms that are typically present in eukaryotes and which are parts of the evolvability apparatus. They are: sex, diploidy, introns and protection against too high selection pressure. These mechanisms give organisms access to ingenious variants (e.g. through new combinations) and avoids stagnations at suboptimal solutions.
No comments:
Post a Comment